5 Fall Paint Color Mistakes (And Simple Fixes)

We love our fall favorites: warm sweaters, cozy campfires and football-watching food and drink. It’s the season of chicken and noodles, fuzzy socks, and the annual debate whether pumpkin spice is still trendy. If you can’t wait to feel all the feels but picked the wrong paint color months ago, then your home might feel more like an icebox than a cozy retreat. The good news? You don’t have to repaint the whole house to fix it. Let’s talk about sneaky paint mistakes that can chill a room, and how to warm things up.

1. Choosing “Cool Gray” Without Checking the Undertones

Gray is the yoga pants of paint—comfortable, versatile, but not always flattering. The problem is that some grays have sneaky blue or purple undertones, which in fall light can make a room feel cold and flat.

Fix it: Layer in warm accents—think terracotta pillows, a wood side table, or even painting just one accent wall in a warmer tone.

2. Sticking With Stark White Walls

Crisp white sounds fresh in spring, but in cooler months that choice can turn sterile faster than you can say “doctor’s office.”

Fix it: If you love white, lean into warmer whites (hint: those with names like “ivory,” “linen,” or “cream” are usually safer bets). Or balance your cool white walls with warm wood tones and textured fabrics.

3. Forgetting How Light Changes in Fall

Summer sunlight is bright and forgiving. Fall sunlight, on the other hand, is like that friend who points out every flaw. Suddenly your perfect beige looks green. And it’s quantity not just quality the of light. As the seasons change so does the amount of daylight. By fall, fewer daylight hours can mean your paint color is often experienced in the softer, artificial glow of lamps during the long evenings.

Fix it: Test paint swatches in multiple spots of the room, especially near windows. Look at them morning, noon, and night. If your color looks moody in fall light (or under your evening bulbs), consider a shade one step warmer.

4. Ignoring the Ceiling (Yes, Really)

White ceilings can sometimes create a stark break from the walls, especially when the walls are a deeper color. It can make the whole room feel chopped up and…cold.

Fix it: Try painting your ceiling a softer off-white, a lighter shade of your wall color, or even the same color as your walls for a cocooning effect. You’d be surprised how much cozier it feels.

5. Going Too Dark, Too Fast

We all love a moody wall moment but paint a small room in an inky navy or charcoal and suddenly it feels like fall has lasted five years.

Fix it: If you’re craving that dramatic vibe, limit dark colors to an accent wall or a cozy nook instead of the whole room. Balance them with warm metals, soft lighting, or lighter furniture. Or choose a deep but warm shade—think cinnamon, olive green, or chocolate brown—rather than pure black or navy.

Closing Thoughts

Paint can be your biggest ally or your trickiest saboteur when it comes to creating a fall-ready home. The key is to think beyond just the color card—consider undertones, light, and how your room will actually feel when the weather turns.

Now, what will you do next to love where you live?

Be sure to visit The Redesign Habit to share your redesign stories or reach out with your questions. We’d love to hear what you’re working on.

For more great stories and ideas please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and subscribe to our YouTube Channel.